BrutalTechTruth

The Myth of the 10x Developer

• Frank • Season 1 • Episode 4

Share episode

The persistent myth of the 10x developer has shaped tech culture for decades, celebrating an impossible ideal while driving real developers toward burnout. Frank challenges this harmful mythology by sharing insights from his life in Italy, where a different approach to productivity offers surprising wisdom for the tech industry.

Drawing from the Italian concept of "il dolce farniente" (the sweetness of doing nothing), Frank introduces us to Marco, a developer who takes daily naps yet consistently produces the cleanest code and solves the toughest problems. This contradicts everything Silicon Valley holds sacred about productivity, suggesting that our metrics might be fundamentally flawed.

The podcast explores how Italian design philosophy—from the sculptural beauty of Olivetti typewriters to Ferrari's focus on emotional experience—offers a revolutionary lens for thinking about software development. Rather than optimizing for speed and feature count, what if we valued the developer who approaches code like a craftsperson? What if we recognized that creativity emerges not from grinding but from the mental space between focused work?

Research confirms what Italians have known for centuries: after about six hours of coding, developers start introducing more bugs than they fix. The alternative isn't laziness but sustainability—embracing "meno ma meglio" (less but better) over the exhausting pursuit of being 10x. By valuing quality over quantity, thoughtfulness over speed, and the full spectrum of human experience over machine-like output, we might create software that's not just functional but meaningful and lasting. Your best developer might not be working at 2 AM—they might be the one taking a nap, understanding that life is too precious for bad code and too short for burnout.

https://brutaltechtrue.substack.com/

https://www.youtube.com/@brutaltechtrue

Support the show

Speaker 1:

Welcome back to the Capybara Lifestyle Podcast, where we explore thoughts, stories and ideas about humans and machines. I'm Frank, and today I want to talk about something that's been bothering me for a while now this whole mythology of the 10x developer. You know, that legendary programmer who supposedly outputs 10 times more code than mere mortals. But here's the thing, and stick with me here, I think your best programmer might actually be the one who takes naps. Yeah, you heard that right. So pour yourself an espresso, find a comfortable spot and let's unpack one of Silicon Valley's most persistent myths. You know, living here in Italy has taught me something about productivity that completely contradicts everything I learned in the tech world. We have this concept here called il dolce farniente, literally the sweetness of doing nothing. And before you roll your eyes and think this is just another lazy European stereotype you roll your eyes and think this is just another lazy European stereotype. Hear me out, because I think this ancient Italian wisdom might be exactly what our burnout-prone tech culture needs to hear.

Speaker 1:

Let me start with a story. Last month, I was in Milan visiting a friend who works at a tech startup Classic setup, ping pong table, beanbags the whole Silicon Valley starter pack transplanted to Italy. And there was this developer, marco, who everyone whispered about, not because he was crushing it with all-nighters and energy drinks, but because every day after lunch he'd disappear for 20 minutes. Turns out he was taking a nap in his car. The American consultants they'd brought in were horrified. Here's a guy literally sleeping on the job. But here's the kicker. Marco consistently solved the toughest problems, wrote the cleanest code and somehow never seemed stressed. While his colleagues were grinding away for 12 hours, making mistakes, creating technical debt, marco would work focused six-hour days and produce brilliance.

Speaker 1:

This got me thinking about the whole 10x developer myth. You know the type. They're supposedly, these coding machines who can output 10 times more than average developers. They're the heroes of Silicon Valley folklore, the ones who build entire systems over a weekend fueled by nothing but caffeine and determination. Every startup wants to hire them. Every developer secretly wants to be them.

Speaker 1:

But what if we're measuring the wrong thing? What if counting lines of code is like judging a writer by how many words they type per minute? It completely misses the point. And this is where Italian design philosophy comes in, and I promise this connects. See, italy has given the world some of the most innovative, beautiful and enduring designs in history. Think about Olivetti. This company created typewriters and computers that were so beautiful they ended up in history. Think about Olivetti. This company created typewriters and computers that were so beautiful they ended up in museums. The Valentine typewriter, designed by Ettore Sottsass in 1969, wasn't just a writing machine. It was a bright red piece of sculpture that happened to type. It made the act of writing feel special, deliberate, meaningful.

Speaker 1:

Now compare that to how we design software today. We optimize for speed, for feature count, for metrics that look good on a dashboard. We celebrate developers who can ship features fastest, who can close the most tickets, who can push the most commits. But what about the developer who spends an afternoon walking in the park thinking about architecture? What about the one who takes time to name variables in a way that tells a story? What about the programmer who says no to features because they'd make the product worse?

Speaker 1:

The Italians have another concept. The Italians have another concept sprezzatura. It means studied carelessness, the art of making something difficult look effortless. It's the opposite of grinding, of wearing your exhaustion like a badge of honor. It's Castiglioni designing the arco lamp, this incredibly engineered floor lamp that looks like it just naturally occurred, like it was always meant to exist in that exact form.

Speaker 1:

I was at a design conference in Florence last year and I met this old designer who'd worked with some of the greats. He told me something I'll never forget. He said in America you have the saying time is money. In Italy we believe time is life. And life is not something you optimize, it's something you taste like good wine. This hit me hard because I'd spent years in the Silicon Valley pressure cooker, where taking a lunch break away from your desk was seen as weakness, where people bragged about working weekends like it was some kind of virtue, where the highest compliment you could get was being called a machine. But machines don't innovate. Machines don't have insights in the shower. Machines don't connect insights in the shower. Machines don't connect disparate ideas while watching clouds drift by. Humans do that, and humans need rest, need beauty, need what the Italians call bellezza, not just visual beauty, but the beauty of a life well lived.

Speaker 1:

Let me tell you about another Italian company, ferrari. Now you might think Ferrari is all about performance, about speed, about being the fastest. But if you talk to their designers, they'll tell you something different. They obsess over the sound of the engine, making it sing. At certain RPMS. They spend months perfecting the curve of a fender, not for aerodynamics, but because it needs to evoke emotion. They understand that a car isn't just transportation, it's theater, it's passion, it's art that happens to move. One of their lead designers once said we don't make the fastest cars, we make cars that make you feel fastest. Think about that. It's not about the metric top speed, it's about the experience, the emotion, the human connection. Now bring this back to software. We've created a culture that celebrates the 10x developer, the one who grinds out code like a Ferrari engine at Redline. But what if we celebrated the developer who writes code like a Ferrari designer, crafts a curve with intention, with beauty, with an understanding that someone else will have to live with this creation.

Speaker 1:

I know a developer in Rome, julia, who embodies this philosophy. She works on financial software not exactly sexy stuff, but her code is a thing of beauty. She names her functions like poetry. She structures her modules like a well-designed building. She takes time to write documentation that actually helps people understand not just what the code does, but why it exists. Her manager once tried to get her to work faster, to be more productive. She looked at him and said you want me to write code. Like Ikea makes furniture or like Casina makes furniture. For those who don't know, casina is this Italian company that makes furniture, so well-crafted, so thoughtfully designed, that pieces from the 1950s are still in daily use today. That shut him up pretty quickly. And here's the thing about Julia. She leaves work at 5 pm, she takes proper lunch breaks, she goes on vacation and actually disconnects. And yet systems she built five years ago are still running smoothly, still a joy to maintain, still teaching junior developers how to think about problems.

Speaker 1:

Oh, those bells again. It's noon now and the whole town is about to shut down for pranzo. For lunch Shops will close, people will go home or to restaurants and for two hours productivity will drop to zero. An American efficiency expert would have a heart attack. But you know what this rhythm, this respect for human needs. It's been working for centuries.

Speaker 1:

I remember when I first moved here from San Francisco, I was frustrated by these breaks, by the inefficiency. I'd bring my laptop to lunch, try to keep working. My Italian colleagues would shake their heads and say, franco, you're missing the point. The pause is not empty. It's full, full of conversation, full of rest, full of life. And slowly I started to get it. Those two-hour lunches weren't wasted time. They were when the real conversations happened, when trust was built, when crazy ideas were thrown around without the pressure of immediate implementation. Some of our best architectural decisions came not from stand-up meetings or planning sessions, but from arguments over pasta, about completely unrelated things that somehow spark the right connection.

Speaker 1:

This brings me back to the 10x developer myth and why it's so toxic. It assumes that developer productivity is like factory work More hours equals more output equals more value. But creative work doesn't scale linearly. In fact, it often scales inversely. The more tired you are, the worse your decisions. The more you grind, the less perspective you have. The more you optimize for output, the less you innovate. There's this fascinating study from Microsoft Research where they tracked developer productivity, and you know what they found After about six hours of focused work, not only does productivity drop, but developers start introducing more bugs than they fix. They're literally creating negative value. But in a culture that celebrates the all-nighter, who's going to admit they need rest?

Speaker 1:

The Italian approach to design and life offers a different model. It's not about being 10x, it's about being sustainable. It's about creating things of lasting value rather than shipping fast and fixing later. It's about understanding that a developer, like a designer, like an artist, is not a production unit, but a creative human being who needs inspiration, rest and yes, beauty in their life. Think about the tools we use.

Speaker 1:

The Italian company Arduino revolutionized maker culture, not by creating the most powerful microcontroller, but by creating the most approachable one. They focused on the experience of learning, of playing, of experimenting. They made electronics feel less like engineering and more like craft, and in doing so they enabled millions of people to become creators. Or consider how Italian fashion houses approach innovation. They don't chase every trend. Gucci doesn't pivot every quarter based on metrics. They have a vision, a philosophy, and they evolve it slowly, thoughtfully. They understand that lasting value comes from depth, not speed. They understand that lasting value comes from depth, not speed. But our tech culture is obsessed with velocity story points per sprint, features shipped per quarter, lines of code per day. We've turned software development into a factory assembly line and then wonder why so much software feels soulless, why technical debt accumulates like plastic in the ocean, why developers burn out and leave the industry.

Speaker 1:

I have a friend who works at a big tech company in Dublin. He told me about their high performer program Developers who consistently delivered above expectations. These were the 10x developers, the ones everyone wanted on their team. But he tracked what happened to them over five years. More than half had burned out and left. Another quarter had moved to management to escape the grind. Only a few were still coding and they'd learned to game the system to appear productive while actually protecting their energy. Meanwhile, the average developers the ones who went home on time, who took their vacation days, who had hobbies outside of coding they were still there, still productive, still learning and growing. They were the tortoises in a culture that only celebrates hares.

Speaker 1:

This isn't an argument for mediocrity. It's an argument for sustainability. It's an argument for recognizing that the best code, like the best design, comes from a place of thoughtfulness, not exhaustion. It comes from developers who have the space to think, to experiment, to make mistakes without the pressure of being 10x. Let me share something personal.

Speaker 1:

A few years ago I was that guy trying to be the 10x developer. I was coding 12 hours a day, weekends, holidays. I was shipping features like crazy. My metrics looked amazing. I was getting promoted, getting recognition, living the Silicon Valley dream, and then I crashed hard, burned out so badly I couldn't look at code for months. That's actually how I ended up in Italy. I came for a two-week vacation and never left, and in the slowness, in the rhythm of Italian life, I rediscovered why I loved programming in the first place. Not for the metrics, not for the velocity, but for the craft, for the elegance of a well-architected system, for the satisfaction of solving a real problem for real people. Now I work differently. I code maybe four or five focused hours a day. I take long walks, I have proper lunches with colleagues where we talk about everything except work. I take naps when I need them and you know what I'm creating the best work of my career, not the most work, the best work.

Speaker 1:

The Italian designers have a principle meno ma meglio. Less but better. It's the opposite of the 10x mentality. It's about doing fewer things but doing them exceptionally well. It's about understanding that true productivity isn't measured in quantity but in quality, in sustainability, in the joy of creation.

Speaker 1:

There's this beautiful story about Achille Castiglione, one of Italy's greatest designers. A client once asked him to design a new chair quickly for a trade show. Chair quickly for a trade show. Instead of rushing, castiglione spent weeks studying how people sit, how they move, how they interact with space. The client was frustrated when was the chair? But when Castiglione finally presented his design, it wasn't just a chair. It was a revelation about sitting, about comfort, about human behavior. That chair is still in production today, still selling, still bringing joy to people's lives.

Speaker 1:

That's the difference between 10x thinking and Italian thinking. One optimizes for speed, the other for timelessness. One burns through developers like disposable resources, the other cultivates craftspeople who grow more valuable with time. So what does this mean for you, listening to this podcast, probably from your desk where you're trying to be productive? It means maybe it's time to question the metrics. Maybe it's time to value the developer who thinks before they code, who refuses to ship garbage, who takes their lunch break and comes back refreshed and inspired. Maybe it's time to recognize that the mythology of the 10x developer is just that a myth, and a harmful one at that, because it makes us value the wrong things, optimize for the wrong outcomes and ultimately create worse software and unhappier humans. The bells are ringing again, afternoon break time. Here. The cafes are filling up with people having their espresso, taking 20 minutes to reset, to transition from one part of the day to another. It's a rhythm as old as these hills and there's wisdom in it.

Speaker 1:

Your best developer might not be the one cranking out code at 2 am. They might be the one who goes home at a reasonable hour, who has interests outside of technology, who brings perspectives from other domains. They might be the one who takes naps, who stares out windows, who writes less code but makes it count, because, in the end, software development isn't about being 10x, it's about being human. It's about creating tools that serve people, that make lives better, that last. And you can't do that when you're exhausted, when you're measuring your worth in lines of code, when you've forgotten why you started coding in the first place.

Speaker 1:

The Italian way offers an alternative not laziness but thoughtfulness, not slowness but sustainability, not less ambition but different ambition, the ambition to create something beautiful, something lasting, something that brings a little more joy into the world. So the next time someone tells you about a 10x developer, ask them 10x, what? 10x? More bugs, 10 times more technical debt, 10x more burnout, or maybe, just maybe. We need developers who are 1x but sustainable, who write code like Italian designers, create objects with care, with craft, with an understanding that what we create outlives us. The sun is setting here. In my little Italian town, the bells will ring once more before evening, marking the end of the work day, and developers across the world will close their laptops, some exhausted from trying to be 10x, others refreshed from understanding that being 1x is perfectly fine if that 1x is thoughtful, sustainable and human.

Speaker 1:

This is the real lesson from Italy, from the masters of design and the philosophy of il dolce far niente. The sweetness of doing nothing isn't about being unproductive. It's about understanding that productivity includes rest, includes beauty, includes the full spectrum of human experience. It's about recognizing that a developer who takes naps might just write better code than one who doesn't. Well, that's my reflection for today, a bit rambling, perhaps, like a good Italian conversation over wine, but I hope it's given you something to think about, maybe permission to question the cult of productivity, to value craft over speed, to take that lunch break without guilt.

Speaker 1:

Thanks for joining me on Capybara Lifestyle. Everyone, remember you're not a machine. You're a human being with the capacity for creativity, for insight, for creating beautiful things. Don't let anyone convince you that being 10 times is more important than being whole. Until next time. This is Frank signing off from Italy, where the coffee is strong, the naps are sacred and the best developers might just be the ones who understand that life is too short for bad code and too precious for burnout. Take care of yourselves and maybe take a nap. Your code will thank you. Ciao, everyone.